A guest post by LP
It’s been awhile since I’ve posted but I’d be remiss not comment on the riot at my alma mater, UC Berkeley, on February 1, 2017 which illustrates the consequences of taking justice into one’s own hands. One only needs to reflect on how sense of right and wrong changes with maturity to appreciate the subjective element. And this can be warped by unique brain wiring (e.g., Ted Kaczynski).
Departing from the usual post format, here are videos illustrating up-close details of more personal costs associated with “justice” administration (aside from the reported half-million dollars in damage to infrastructure and surrounding businesses) by the frenzied or not-so-bright. This is a 46-second clip taken by Mixed Martial Artist (MMA) Jake Shields’ girlfriend of his confrontation with Antifa (derived from “Anti-Fascists” and comprised of anarcho-communists as far as I know) after saving a Trump supporter from being beaten to death. If you can’t hear the conversation, as mentioned in the YouTube comment section, these rioters reasoned that Milo Yiannopoulos can’t be Jewish because he’s Greek.
To quote Shields, “I don’t think those people are capable of rationalizing. I think they’ve switched their brains to where if you have a different opinion of them, you’re a Nazi. I hate Nazis, too, but who determines what’s a Nazi?… There were hundreds of people cheering on, ‘Get the Nazi,’ and I went up and started arguing with them. Why’s this guy a Nazi? What did he say to make him a Nazi? No one could say.”
Without provocation, an Antifa member pepper-sprayed a woman wearing a “Make Bitcoin Great Again” hat. Anarcho-Capitalist Stefan Molyneux interviews her about this incident in this 21-minute video:
Meanwhile, as the night’s events unfolded, law enforcement’s capacity to assist others was limited as a would-be Milo Yiannopoulos event attendee described:
After about 2 1/2 hours, an officer told them, “if you guys want to go out of the building, you need to go now.” Walsh asked if officers would escort them. “They said, ‘It’ll make things worse for you,’ ” she said.
Walsh and her female friend made it to their car in a parking garage, where, in a surreal moment, a lurking stranger had mistaken their car as belonging to Yiannapoulos’ entourage and was hoping to see him.
They tried to drive out of the garage but the exit was blocked by barricades and a dumpster, she said. Two maintenance workers said they could not help them but gave them the phone number to the campus police department. She called but was told officers were “a little busy” though they’d try to send someone.
As it happened, Walsh had grabbed some anti-Yiannopoulos printed material (“propaganda literature,” she said) so she put it on the dashboard to fool the protesters – and held onto her pepper spray.
She drove behind another car heading to the exit, where several protesters moved the obstruction aside to let them pass, which took a while.
“They said ‘We’ll help you.’ They let us out,” she said. “That literature saved my life, I’m sure of it. It was insane.”
Styxhexenhammer666 contrasts political protests by the left versus the right and offers conclusions (which aren’t surprising) on where the vast majority of the violence comes from in this 12-minute video:
I can’t attest to the accuracy of his account of history, so corrections and comments are welcome. The narrative that the rioters were outsiders (unaffiliated with UC Berkeley) who took over what was to be a peaceful demonstration makes sense. Some protesters disapprove of Antifa’s methods I’m sure. However, if protesters believe Antifa are right-wing agent provocateurs, they should clarify their disapproval and arrange to ostracize rioters. Plan to be seen shouting them down or leaving to avoid being caught up in it.
Antifa has seemingly been accepted at leftist demonstrations for some time though (e.g. the Occupy movement). Perhaps young, college-aged protesters are too inexperienced and short-sighted about consequences to pursue effective methods for dealing with infiltration as others asserted. However, I’ll believe their rejection of Antifa when I see it. Most viewers saw what I saw – protesters mostly cheering and celebrating. So, how is it not reasonable to interpret their actions as condoning stupidity and senseless violence? After a cool-down period, granting students’ “thought leaders” time to reflect and come to their senses on how to respond in a way that represents the campus and student community, writers at The Daily Californian (the campus newspaper) defended the rioters:
Neil Lawrence wrote, “Behind those bandanas and black T-shirts were faces of your fellow UC Berkeley and Berkeley City college students, of women, of people of color, of queer and trans people.”
Desmond Meagley wrote, “Condemning protesters same as condoning hate speech… I put my safety and my freedom on the line because letting Yiannopoulos speak was more terrifying to me than potential injury or arrest.”
At this time, the right-wing agent provocateur narrative may also be unraveling. It appears that UC Berkeley students may have been among the Antifa rioters’ ranks that night. However, rioters’ identities are still under FBI investigation.
I seem to recall a time when there was less extremism. Although college students aren’t all like this as they, too, represent different points across the political spectrum, in hindsight, it just seems the penchant for this craziness was not there to this degree. I attended Berkeley in the 1990s and was present for the discontinuation of Affirmative Action. Students’ reactions were uneventful compared to how riled up these protesters became over a visiting speaker they disagreed with. This leaves me wondering if it’ll get worse than this.
2 thoughts on “Commentary on the Recent UC Berkeley Riot at Milo Yiannopoulous’ Speaking Event”
I expect it to get worse. There’s much more at stake for the left than there was in the case of Affirmative Action at Berkeley. This is about who controls the government of the Untied States. There are some well-heeled leftists behind the activism (e.g., George Soros). And the mainstream media won’t let it die. Every evening I overhear the hysteria being broadcast by NBC News, and I’m sure that it’s the same on ABC, CBS, and CNN. If it’s not “Trump is a fascist warmonger,” it’s “Trump is a heartless, anti-refugee monster” — not in so many words (on the networks), of course, but the messages are clear. And if those themes get tiresome, there will be others to take their place.
Yeah, people are hysterical about Trump. And, unfortunately, conflict escalation between the right and left adds a risk to the whole nation. I’ve become more aware of how foreign enemies looks for fissures in the social fabric to exploit. Recently, I listened to Peter Navarro’s (one of Trump’s advisors) “Crouching Tiger: What China’s Militarism Means for the World” audiobook (as, under my current conditions, listening is easier than reading) and I realized that countries like China look for social discontent and conflict like this one. So aside from Soros, there’s that too.
I spoke to a friend after finishing that book and, as he is an avid Facebook person, he then realized that a lot of the Facebook social justice warrior-type outbursts come from people who write as if they aren’t adept at English. As I relayed the contents of Navarro’s book, it dawned on him how prevalent influence from foreign government agents might be.
Within my (and my friend’s) microcosm, I’ve found that a number of people who lean right (particularly if they’re military or in national security) understand why we can’t allow political discourse to devolve like that. However, it seems many on the left (that we’ve witnessed) are more oblivious to what’s happening outside of our nation and too busy being hysterical.
Anyhow, Navarro’s book was a good introduction to issues in US-China relations though he notably has one of the more pessimistic outlooks – and I’m aware of the great variety of opinions out there on this matter. It’s a good read (or listen) for people who have a strong budding interest in this area, like me. It might not have a lot of offer to those who already have specialized knowledge however.
Comments are closed.